Lets start with the complaints:
1. It was too awesome. Too awesome in a bad way, like, seeing so many bands over the week just made the whole thing kind of numbing. Like “oh, you got uppercutted in the nuts during Fucked Up’s set on Saturday night? That is nothing: I went to a BBQ that the members of WIRE were at. Oh yeah? I had a beer with Mark Sultan at the Legion!” That kind of thing. There was more awesome squeezed into one week than many people experience over a lifetime. I suppose I just like my awesomeness spread around a little so the rest of my year doesn’t seem so fucking pathetic.
2. The outdoor shows. The venue was fine. The weather was nice. I just prefer seeing bands in a dank club. This is mainly because I am not an “outdoors” person, and also I honestly think that it is harder to connect with a band when it is sunny outside.
Also: why were there so many cops lingering around, acting like total fascists. I passed one in particular that looked like he was ready to beat my ass down for no reason, other than I was staring at the sound-measuring-device that they kept using to make sure it didn’t get “too loud.” Cop count at the indoor shows: 0.
Now for my positives:
1. The bands, specifically local ones, were particularly impressive this year. I know that I have been guilty of it in the past, but so many Sled Island rundowns have seemed so fucking obvious, and it doesn’t seem like people are taking as many chances as they should be (illustrated by a few really poorly attended shows – like Hunter Gatherer, a new local band who put on one of the best shows of the week, had like 8 people watching). Really – you saw Grizzly Bear, then The May Shi and finished with Blitzen Trapper? Good for you. The Calgary scene is amazing right now, and it shouldn’t take a writeup in Pitchfork for locals to pay attention to it.
2. The shows were more or less run like clockwork. I can’t think of many times we were left waiting for things to get moving, and I think this is a testament to the volunteers.
3. The weird side shows at places like Tubby Dog, or in some basements (my band Endangered Ape ended up playing a really fun basement show with The Ex-Boyfriends, complete with seizure inducing strobes and a fog machine). Though these shows weren’t officially Sled Island promoted, I hope that more of this kind of innovation happens in the future.
4. The audiences were generally attentive, easy going, which made almost all of the shows I saw that much better. Save for the secret shows (where bands like WIRE, Okkerville River and Broken Social Scene played at 2 am when everyone was exhausted from rocking out in the previous 8 hours). People – especially other bands – were really nice and it is nice to come away with a few new friends and contacts.
Bands seen in 2008: The list so-far (64 Unique bands). Bands with * were particularly good.
Atrophy Manuscript (x2)
Azeda Booth
BBQ (Mark Sultan) (x2) *
Beiruit
The Breeders
Broken West
Built to Spill
Cold War Kids
Crudo (Mike Patton / Dan the Automator)
The Cure *
Cryptomaniacs (x2) ***
Dead Confederate
Death Cab for Cutie
Deerhunter *
Destroyer (X2) **
Devon Williams *
Drive By Truckers
Elliott Brood
The Ex-Boyfriends (x2) *
The Flaming Lips *
Fleet Foxes (x2)
Flight of the Conchords
Fucked Up (x2) ***
Grand Archives
Gutter Twins
Hayden
Hazard Lights (x2)
Heat Ray ***
The Hives *
Hot Little Rocket
Hunter Gatherer *
Langhorne Slim
Mars Volta
Mogwai
Mt Royal (x2) **
The National
The New Pornographers
Of Montreal
Okkervil River
The Ostrich ***
Portastic
Presidents of The USA
Rambling Ambassadors *
REM
Jonathan Richman
Rogue Wave
Secret Machines
Seven Story Redhead
The Shaky Hands
SIDS (x2) ***
65 Days of Static
Suicide Wrists **
The Summerlad **
The Sweater Contest
Throw Me The Statue *
The Throwaways ***
Twilight Hotel
The Void
The Wet Secrets
The Whigs
Wire
Women (x2) ***
Yeahsayer
Yo La Tengo







